A fundamental question

Question 1. Is Jesus God?

So tick the box it is multiple choice – Y or N?

Correct answer of course is Y… or ‘maybe‘.

Why maybe? Cos there is a flaw in the question. The question assumes I know what/who ‘God’ is. The assumption is I have the ability to define ‘God’ and then decide if Jesus meets that definition. Is ‘Jesus’ what (who?) I know?

What if we don’t know who God is? Then we would not be able to answer that question. So to pass this exam I need to find out who God is and then I will be able to answer the question. And that is where the majority of ‘systematics’ begin. They start with the doctrine of God before Christology; this being the normal order. Not sure if Jesus wrote a systematic theoogy it would make it as a best seller!!

If (a big conditional word) you have seen me, you have seen the Father. Jesus did not offer the knowledge of God but to know who this God is.

God is revealed not in propositional terms but through the saving activity that comes to a fullness in Jesus:

Long ago God spoke to our ancestors in many and various ways by the prophets, but in these last days he has spoken to us by (ἐν: en) a Son.

Jesus words and actions are where we see God. Is Jesus ‘God’? Well what we can certainly say is that God is like Jesus who is the exact image of the invisible God.

Ancient pagan cultures with their polytheism are somewhat understandable. There is a ‘god’ that oversees one aspect of life. Then maybe some move beyond a simple corporate group of gods to a boss god (Zeus for example) and maybe beyond that to there is only one god. But the real issue is and what is the character of that ‘god’ (who is this one god?). If the character is different to that of Jesus we still have a ‘god’ and not ‘God’. That is why we have to ask, for example, a question beyond ‘Is Allah God’, to a more pertinent question ‘is the Christian God, God?’ There are many variations of the Christian God out there. And there is a Martin variety as well. That ‘God’ is shaped by the Jesus that the Scriptures bear witness to – OK that is what I like to think. I hope in part that is true but if honest I am sure my ‘god’ is shaped by a number of other factors too.

There are probably a lot of sub-gods around! I can line up my texts to defend the rightness of my beliefs and I can do it in such a way that the texts say I am right but the god of my beliefs look nothing like Jesus. OOOOOFFF.

I love how Systematic Theologies are often called ‘Dogmatics’. I realise that the word is not being used in the popular sense of ‘I am right and you are wrong’ but too often there is something reflected there of that approach. I think a Jesus centred approach is a lot less dogmatic and much more chalenging.

A few areas where I have moved over the years or are willing to listen to alternative approaches I will bullet point below (I will leave you to decide, should you wish, where I have definitely (dogmatically?) moved:

  • Away from all are lost/ damned except for those who have prayed the sinner’s prayer to
    All are saved except for those who reject Jesus, or better put: all who receive Jesus are saved and all who reject Jesus are lost.
  • The possibility of ultimate reconciliation as God will do everything to achieve that and the gates of the eternal city are never closed.
  • That Jesus did not bear the wrath of God but that the Triune God was together reconciling the world.
  • That I don’t have to wrestle with the contradiction of a God who desires all to come to the knowledge of the truth but only selects some. Election being for a purpose, corporate and that there is only one eternally elect Person.
  • That salvation is not about escaping hell but being delivered from the realm of sin and death, thus entering into the purpose of being alive.

Many, many more items I could put there. I am not afraid to be agnostic on certain aspects. I had a call from someone I respect who said they had word for me. After giving it I asked about one aspect ‘are you sure about…?’ He replied with ‘I am sure about Jesus… everything else I am less sure about’.

That response will help us not simply create a construct, and help the ‘god’ we claim to have sight of to be more like ‘God’ as we journey.

Martin, ‘Is Jesus God?’

My answer ‘maybe’!!!!!!

One thought on “A fundamental question”

  1. Okay Martin: I’ve been thinking about this since you posted it. Here’s the issue for me.
    I like Jesus as presented in the Bible. Interesting fellow. Challenging. On the right side of things in terms of caring for the other and marginalized, rejecting oppressive religion, and creating community. I am down with all of that. A real challenge to imperialism and patriarchy in multiple forms.
    And I am fascinated that this story about Jesus is included in the Bible. The Bible is a mix of literatures, and books from different periods. It leans one way or another depending on what you read. But overall, It is the result of a patriarchal religion for the OT and continuing on in the NT. I consider patriarchy antithetical to all I see in Jesus’ teachings.
    So that leads me to question the source of the story. Can I believe it at all? Because of its foundation in patriarchal religion I have to question anything I find in the OT and much of the NT.
    You could say I am trying to build a Bible that fits my bias. And that’s fair. But I see Jesus as challenging patriarchal, imperialistic religion so it means that he also rejected much of it or ‘completes’ it.
    What to do? I reject writings as scripture and something I should follow when women and others are dehumanized. The great achievement of Jesus, in his story, is that he humanized those who were dehumanized in his time and place – women, Samaritans, gentiles.
    How do I accept that this story in a book which I cannot accept, is true? How do I understand this. Is it just a fantastical, aspirational story with some character named Jesus? How do I know there is some reality behind it.
    The delegitimizing aspects of the writings become present again all through the NT. Though they are also often challenged in the NT. Do I do like Martin Luther and just come up with a list of books I like? I guess if he could do it, so can I.
    So that is my place of struggle. What should I accept about this story and why? What is true and what is truth?
    Your thoughts?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Perspectives